What Do Writing Coaches Do?

We coach, of course, but that’s a bit vague. What do we do with papers?

Customers usually ask if we “grade” papers. I say yes, but really that’s not a good description. We don’t even use grades. We “score” final drafts using a numerical rubric, but that’s a small and relatively insignificant part of what we do. In the same way “assessing” or “evaluating” is only the subjective part at the end.

We “critique” papers, but that has such a negative connotation; I don’t like it. “Edit” doesn’t quite cover what we do, since there’s much more to coaching than fixing errors. And “edit” implies that we make the corrections ourselves instead of directing students in how to do it. Nope; that won’t work.

We “comment” on papers. That’s nice and positive, but a bit nebulous. It can mean almost anything. Same goes for “respond.”

We both “encourage” and “correct.” Those two words cover the kind of balance we like to achieve–pointing out both the positive aspects of a student’s writing and the parts needing work. But I just don’t like the idea that it takes two words to describe what we do. It makes crafting marketing slogans and ads pretty difficult.

Do I need to invent a new word? If any reader out there has a suggestion, I’m all ears.